Pole Tide Paradox Reconciled?

(spoiler: If you have read Chapter 13 of Mathematical Geoenergy1, you know where this is going)

The oceanic pole tide has historically been treated as a quasi-static equilibrium adjustment of the oceans to the Earth’s 433-day (~14 month) Chandler wobble. However, observed sea-level records present severe spatial discrepancies — most notably the extreme high-latitude amplification in semi-enclosed basins such as the Gulf of Bothnia in the northern Baltic Sea, where sea-level excursions exceed theoretical predictions by nearly an order of magnitude. This post reviews the historical discovery and mathematical derivation of the classical pole tide, examines why its classical tesseral potential (sin⁡2θ\sin 2\theta) fails to account for high-latitude maxima, and presents a physical and mathematical framework wherein the 14-month Chandler signal emerges as a stroboscopic, modular alias of the zonal (m=0m=0) lunar draconic fortnightly tide gated by an annual impulse train. Not to say that the Chandler wobble and pole tide are not related; in fact, they are but the link is more to a common mechanism.

Discovery and Theoretical Origins

The discovery of the pole tide followed a classic sequence of astronomical deduction, geodynamic formulation, and subsequent tidal-gauge isolation.

Flowchart illustrating historical estimates and theories related to Earth's nutation and celestial wobble, including contributions from Euler, Chandler, Newcomb, and Bakhuyzen & Christie.


In 1765, Leonhard Euler proved that any rotating, biaxial, rigid spheroid whose rotation axis departs slightly from its figure axis undergoes a free Eulerian nutation. For Earth’s flattening ratio:

TEuler=AC−A≈305 daysT_{\text{Euler}} = \frac{A}{C – A} \approx 305 \text{ days}

where A and C are the equatorial and polar principal moments of inertia, respectively.

In 1891, the American astronomer Seth Carlo Chandler analyzed decades of precise stellar latitude observations, demonstrating that the true wobble had an amplitude of ≈0.7′′\approx 0.7” and a period of approximately 433 days (~14 months), completely at odds with the rigid-body calculation.

In 1892, Simon Newcomb reconciled the 128-day gap by explaining that the Earth is not rigid. Instead, it yields elastically in its mantle and fluidly in its global oceans. As the instantaneous rotational axis wanders relative to the crust, the centrifugal potential shifts:

𝛀(t)=Ω(m1(t)m2(t)1+m3(t))\mathbf{\Omega}(t) = \Omega \begin{pmatrix} m_1(t) \\ m_2(t) \\ 1 + m_3(t) \end{pmatrix}

The time-dependent centrifugal potential perturbation Φp\Phi_p acting on the fluid envelope is:

Φp=−12Ω2r2sin⁡(2θ)[m1(t)cos⁡λ+m2(t)sin⁡λ]\Phi_p = -\frac{1}{2} \Omega^2 r^2 \sin(2\theta) \left[ m_1(t)\cos\lambda + m_2(t)\sin\lambda \right]

where:

  • θ\theta is geographic latitude,
  • λ\lambda is longitude,
  • m1,m2m_1, m_2 are the angular components of polar motion.

Newcomb termed this forced 14-month sea-surface deformation the pole tide.

Observational confirmation was not immediate as the equilibrium amplitude of this tide in the open ocean is exceedingly small:

ζeq≈(1+k2−h2)Φpg≈5 to 8 mm\zeta_{\text{eq}} \approx \frac{(1 + k_2 – h_2)\Phi_p}{g} \approx 5 \text{ to } 8 \text{ mm}

where h2≈0.61h_2 \approx 0.61 and k2≈0.30k_2 \approx 0.30 are the Love numbers accounting for solid-Earth elastic yield and self-gravitation.

Despite the low signal-to-noise ratio, Christie (1895) in the United States and Bakhuyzen (1912) in the Netherlands successfully isolated a 14-month, 1-to-2 cm sea-level modulation from multi-decadal coastal tide records, establishing the pole tide as an empirical reality2.

The wobble explanation of why the tide should vanish at the poles

The geometric signature of the classical pole tide is governed by the second-degree, first-order tesseral spherical harmonic:

P21(sin⁡θ)=3sin⁡θcos⁡θ=32sin⁡(2θ)P_2^1(\sin\theta) = 3\sin\theta\cos\theta = \frac{3}{2}\sin(2\theta)

The term sin⁡(2θ)=2sin⁡θcos⁡θ\sin(2\theta) = 2\sin\theta\cos\theta represents the product of two orthogonal projections, the z tilt projection and the r⟂r_\perp lever arm:

              Z (Spin Axis)
▲
│ Pole (θ = 90°): Lever arm
r⟂r_{\perp} = 0
│ ──> No lateral centrifugal shift
│
│ • P(r, θ)
│ /│
│ / │
│ / │ z = r sin(θ)
│ / │ (Axis tilt projection)
│ / │
│ / │
└───────┴──────► X, Y (Equator, θ = 0°)
r⟂r_{\perp} = r cos(θ)
(Equator: z = 0 ──> No first-order tilt)

The radial distance to the rotational axis is cos⁡θ∝r⟂\cos\theta \propto r_\perp. Centrifugal acceleration Fc=Ω2r⟂F_c = \Omega^2 r_\perp scales with distance from the axis. Thus, at the geographic poles (θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ), r⟂=0r_\perp = 0. Here, the spin axis merely tilts in place beneath the observer; with no perpendicular lever arm, the centrifugal perturbation is zero.

The coordinate projection along the axis is sin⁡θ∝z\sin\theta \propto z, in other words. the displacement of the tilted axis relative to the mean axis scales with vertical distance from the center of mass. In the equatorial plane (θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ), z = 0, so that a pure tilt about the origin produces zero first-order variation in radial distance.

Because it requires both a non-zero height (z) and a non-zero lever arm (r⟂r_\perp), the perturbation achieves its maximum strictly at mid-latitudes:

ddθsin⁡(2θ)=2cos⁡(2θ)=0⟹θ=45∘\frac{d}{d\theta}\sin(2\theta) = 2\cos(2\theta) = 0 \implies \theta = 45^\circ

The classical theory dictates that the pole tide must decay toward zero at high latitudes.

The Bothnian anomaly defies the mechanism geometry

Tide-gauge networks throughout Northern Europe reveal an empirical distribution that directly inverts the classical prediction:

Station Location Latitude (θ\theta)Classical Equilibrium AmplitudeObserved ,14-Month AmplitudeRatio (Obs / Eq)
English Channel / North Sea51∘N−53∘N51^\circ\text{N} – 53^\circ\text{N}∼5 mm\sim 5 \text{ mm}8−15 mm8 – 15 \text{ mm} ≈2−3×\approx 2 – 3\times
Southern Baltic (Degerby)60∘N60^\circ\text{N}∼4.5 mm\sim 4.5 \text{ mm}10−15 mm10 – 15 \text{ mm}≈3×\approx 3\times
Northern Gulf of Bothnia (Kemi Ratan)64∘N−66∘N64^\circ\text{N} – 66^\circ\text{N} ∼3.5 mm\sim 3.5 \text{ mm}30−55 mm 30 – 55 \text{ mm} ≈10−15×\approx 10 – 15\times

Empirically, instead of decaying as sin⁡(2θ)\sin(2\theta) toward the Arctic, the amplitude expands monotonically up the Gulf of Bothnia, reaching its global coastal maximum in the sub-polar cul-de-sac of the Bothnian Bay in the northern Baltic.

Scatter plot showing observed values in millimeters on the Y-axis and latitude in degrees on the X-axis, with data points labeled for North Bothnia, English Channel, and Southern Baltic. A dotted line represents classical equilibrium.

Hydrodynamic and Meteorological Hypotheses

Physical oceanography has attempted to explain this discrepancy through local basin dynamics:

  • Wind Setup Funneling: Southerly wind stress associated with the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) pushes water through the Baltic. As water enters the Bothnian Bay across the shallow Quarken sill (h<20 mh < 20 \text{ m}), the one-dimensional momentum balance forces a steep surface slope: ∂η∂x≈τwρgh\frac{\partial \eta}{\partial x} \approx \frac{\tau_w}{\rho g h}
  • Basin Seiche Antinodes: The Baltic acts as a long-wave resonator with an amphidromic nodal region near the Åland Islands and an antinode at the northern boundary.

While these local hydrodynamics account for local amplification factors of shallow water, they rely on an external weather forcing that happens to possess quasi-periodic power near 14 months. They do not explain why the fundamental forcing frequency itself matches the Chandler wobble across global decadal spectra.

Re-evaluating Causality: The Lunar Draconic Fortnightly Hypothesis

The severe shortcomings of the centrifugal P21P_2^1 potential at high latitudes invite a fundamental physical re-examination: What if the Chandler period itself is not an internal elastic resonance excited by random atmospheric noise, but rather an aliased response to an astronomical forcing that is naturally maximized at the poles?

First consider that direct gravitational tidal potentials do not share the P21P_2^1 mid-latitude cutoff if they are longitudinally symmetric (wavenumber m = 0), i.e. they are invariant across longitudes. This is because long-period tides generated by the Moon’s declinational excursions (the draconic or nodical tides) average over the diurnal cycle, eliminating longitudinal dependence. The resulting potential is governed by the Legendre polynomial of degree 2, order 0:

P20(sin⁡θ)=12(3sin2⁡θ−1)P_2^0(\sin\theta) = \frac{1}{2}\left(3\sin^2\theta – 1\right)

A graph displaying potential value against latitude, featuring a dotted orange line and blue markers indicating the equator, node, and pole.

Evaluating P20(sin⁡θ)P_2^0(\sin\theta) across latitudes:

  • Equator (θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ): P20(0)=−0.5P_2^0(0) = -0.5
  • Nodal zero-crossing (θ≈35.26∘):3sin2⁡θ−1=0(\theta \approx 35.26^\circ): 3\sin^2\theta – 1 = 0
  • North Pole (θ=90∘):P20(1)=+𝟏.𝟎(\theta = 90^\circ): P_2^0(1) = \mathbf{+1.0}

A forcing with wavenumber m = 0 doubles in magnitude at the pole relative to the equator and increases monotonically across the sub-polar and polar seas.

The stroboscopic aliasing mechanism is the spoiler in explaining everything. Consider first that the Moon’s nodal crossing cycle—the draconic month—has a period of:

Td≈27.2122 daysT_d \approx 27.2122 \text{ days}

Because tidal deformation depends on the square of the declination (sin2⁡δ\sin^2\delta) or is symmetric across the equatorial plane, the primary declinational forcing recurs every half-cycle, known as the draconic fortnightly cycle:

Tdf=Td2≈13.6061 days⟹fdf=1Tdf≈0.0735 cycles/day (cpd)T_{df} = \frac{T_d}{2} \approx 13.6061 \text{ days} \quad \implies \quad f_{df} = \frac{1}{T_{df}} \approx 0.0735 \text{ cycles/day (cpd)}

Now consider the coupling of this continuous zonal carrier to an annual impulse train or gating envelope (e.g., seasonal stratification, solar insolation, annual sea-ice formation, or annual air-mass exchange):

Ta≈365.2422 days⟹fa=1Ta≈0.00274 cpdT_a \approx 365.2422 \text{ days} \quad \implies \quad f_a = \frac{1}{T_a} \approx 0.00274 \text{ cpd}

Modular arithmetic of the interaction generates the aliasing. The ratio of annual to draconic fortnightly cycles defines the phase progression:

N=TaTdf=365.242213.6061≈26.844 cycles/yearN = \frac{T_a}{T_{df}} = \frac{365.2422}{13.6061} \approx 26.844 \text{ cycles/year}

When sampled or gated stroboscopically at the annual interval TaT_a, frequencies fold modulo the annual sampling frequency. The fractional residual Δϕ\Delta \phi is:

Δϕ=N(mod1)=26.844−26=0.844 cycles/year\Delta \phi = N \pmod 1 = 26.844 – 26 = 0.844 \text{ cycles/year}

Computing the beat period corresponding to this residual:

Tbeat=TaΔϕ=365.2422 days0.84406≈𝟒𝟑𝟐.𝟕𝟐 daysT_{\text{beat}} = \frac{T_a}{\Delta \phi} = \frac{365.2422 \text{ days}}{0.84406} \approx \mathbf{432.72 \text{ days}}

This result is mathematically identical to the observed Chandler wobble period (∼433d\sim 433d).

Flowchart illustrating tidal drivers and their effects on astronomical cycles, including lunar draconic fortnightly effects, non-linear convolution with an annual gating function, modular aliasing calculations, and the resulting baseband alias period.

Comparison
The hypothesis that the Chandler period and its corresponding sea-level signal originate via modular aliasing of the lunar draconic tide resolves the high-latitude amplification paradox:

Diagnostic Metric Classical Elastic Wobble ModelLunar Draconic Aliasing Model
Primary DriverRandom atmospheric/oceanic churn exciting internal Euler nutation Gravitational lunar torque on Earth’s oblateness (C – A)
Spatial HarmonicP21∝sin⁡(2θ)(Tesseral,m=1)P_2^1 \propto \sin(2\theta) (Tesseral, m=1)P20=12(3sin2⁡θ−1)(Zonal,m=0)P_2^0 = \frac{1}{2}(3\sin^2\theta – 1) (Zonal, m=0)
Theoretical Polar Amplitude 0 mm0 \text{ mm} (Vorticity axis pivots without lever arm) Maximum (Radial potential doubles relative to equator)
Bothnian Bay AnomalyRequires extreme dynamic amplification factors (>10×>10\times) Naturally aligns with the polar-maximized zonal potential
Period StabilityVariable period depending on mantle dissipative Q factorMathematically locked to the draconic cycle aliased to annual

As with all these models, the best way to proceed is to compare to actual data. Using the approach as described in Chapter 12 Mathematical Energy on Wave Energy, we set up the convolution of the tidal sinusoids with the annual impulse comb to generate a forcing manifold. Then apply the LTE modulation to generate a type of winding response.

The following is for the Kemi MSL station in northern Finland at the upper reaches of the Bothnian Gulf

A line graph displaying two sets of standardized data over time: the first graph shows the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) from 1880 to 2020, with blue representing NAO and orange representing the model; the second graph shows KEMI_N12 with similar color coding. Both graphs illustrate fluctuations in data with shaded areas indicating held-out periods.

Oulu in Finland

Time series plot comparing NAO and model standardized data from 1880 to 2020, featuring two panels: the upper panel for NAO and the lower panel for OULU, each showcasing fluctuations with a highlighted section around 2000.

Most of these stations seem to be in phase, so the set of Baltic time-series can be averaged and fit again.

Line graph comparing standardized NAO and its model from 1880 to 2020, with emphasis on data held out from 2000-2005.

Note that in the above I have been using a multiple-leg fitting approach, whereby I take a common forcing manifold for NAO and the MSL data. The windings are essentially 180 degrees apart which makes sense from the inverted barometric effect but it may be that the dipole measurement is reversed here. Whichever it may be, both the atmospheric NAO and the tidal stations do indeed have a common mechanism.

The amplitude of the windings act essentially as the scaling of the tidal values. Both the fundamental winding value and the harmonics show the same latitudinal dependence as cited elsewhere.

Map showing 1x, 4x, and 7x winding patterns in the Baltic region, with circle sizes indicating winding amplitude. Each map includes specific mean values for Baltic data.

a

Bar chart displaying absolute amplitudes of 42 tidal factors related to NAO, with varying heights representing different amplitudes measured in arbitrary units.
A time series graph showing the NAO (North Atlantic Oscillation) composed sum of 42 tidal factors from 1950 to 2000. The x-axis represents the years, while the y-axis displays amplitude in arbitrary units, with values fluctuating between -6 and 6.


The Arctic Oscillation fit is similar to the NAO, with the same set of windings. Only the phase is reversed below, with the NAO having a low-pass filter applied, so that the faster windings come through on AO.

Graph showing standardized NAO and model values from 1880 to 2022, with highlighted area for 2000-2005, in the top half. The bottom half displays standardized AO and model values over the same period. Blue line represents NAO, while the orange line indicates the model. Blue line for AO and corresponding model shown in red.

The logical next connection to test is an index at the other pole, so here is the southern annular mode (SAM)

The image displays two graphs comparing the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) and Southern Annular Mode (SAM) over time from 1880 to 2023. The top graph shows a blue line for NAO and an orange line for its model, with a highlighted period between 2000 and 2005. The bottom graph features SAM with a similar color scheme and also highlights the same period. Both graphs depict standardized values and fluctuations in the indices.

The windings for NAO are quite apparent, below from the winding scalogram applied:

Winding scalograms comparing NAO data and model results over time. The left panel shows observed data with a mean spectrum and fitted winding numbers, while the right panel displays model predictions after IR correction. Color gradient represents log2 power values across different years.

Conclusion

It may be all tidal forcing after all.

The designation of a pole tide demonstrates the challenge of explicating the observations from what is expected form spatial potential analysis. While the Chandler wobble itself undoubtedly tilts the centrifugal potential in a P21P_2^1 harmonic, the inability of that harmonic to explain high-latitude sea-level data points toward another mechanism. I suppose it could be amplification from wind funneling or seiche antinodes, but the common-mode mechanism of draconic lunar torque driving both CW and the MSL cycle is more parsimonious and possibly more plausible.

Consider that the modular aliasing of the m=0m=0 lunar draconic fortnightly tide across the annual solar cycle provides both:

  • An exact mathematical derivation of the 433-day period (365.2422/0.84406≈432.7d365.2422 / 0.84406 \approx 432.7 d).
  • A zonal P20P_2^0 potential geometry whose intrinsic maximum resides at the poles, resolving the Bothnian amplification paradox from first physical principles

Perhaps it could still be called a pole tide, but if the polar wobble doesn’t cause it the naming would now be misguided. Consider the perhaps absurd notion that the Chandler wobble is on the same scale as the LOD changes signifying variation of angular motion — this is orders of magnitude larger than the CW kick, yet there is no such thing as an “LOD tide” (except by me of course, see Chapter 12 in the reference below, where it explains ENSO and AMO) .

References

  1. P. Pukite, D. Challou, and D.Coyne, Mathematical Geoenergy, (Wiley, 2018), https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/book/10.1002/9781119434351 ↩︎
  2. S. R. Dickman, The self-consistent dynamic pole tide in global oceans, Geophysical Journal International, Volume 81, Issue 1, April 1985, Pages 157–174, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-246X.1985.tb01356.x https://watermark02.silverchair.com/81-1-157.pdf ↩︎

Search for the Hidden Manifold

An algorithm that simultaneously optimizes the model fit to two disparate climate indices while keeping the hidden latent manifold constant. The two indices chosen, AMO and PDO, occur in separated ocean basins and show longer term variations, so that a multi-scale fit is necessary. The hidden latent manifold uses as a starting point the calibrated tidal factors needed to match the Earth’s LOD variations — the same torques that presumably cause the ocean’s thermocline to slosh. Only a slight perturbation to the tidal factors — amounting to a 0.996 correlation coefficient (instead of 1.0) to the calibrated LOD was needed to tweak the manifold during the fitting process.

AMO

PDO

Can then use PDO as a seed to model NINO4 and IOD-East

NINO4

IOD-East

The manifolds are all aligned (below) with slight jogs that were caused by letting the fitting routine to proceed beyond the locked manifold stage.

Have not included NAO in this set of comparisons yet since NAO has an interesting relationship to AMO. If the value of AMO from 12 months back is fed back into the current AMO with a negative sign (a delay differential), and then the correlation coefficient is computed, that value is significant, especially on more recent values.

The plot below is an expedited fit that does a delay differential on the AMO model to emulate the NAO time series. Note that the fit degrades in the years 1890-1900 and 1915-1920, the same years that the above pot shows anti-correlations.

NAO

Also averaged Baltic MSL time-series. Has a dominant LTE mode, higher in winding frequency than the other indices.

Baltic MSL

It is so strong that other LTE windings do not contribute much to the variation in extremes.

NAO unfiltered

The north Atlantic oscillation (NAO) is a most erratic climate index, often showing full cycles spanning less than a year. It is intimidating to consider that the raw NAO time-series can even be modelled, as it is often characterized as a weather precursor/indicator for Europe . Four years ago, I posted this to the ATTP blog:

Text excerpt discussing tidal cycles, boundary-element models, and data analysis techniques related to the NAO and Arctic Oscillation.
Graph depicting dLOD fit to NAO from 1950 to 2020, showing data and model comparisons in intensity.

This was fit applying the usual LTE model: a semi-annual stroboscopic sample of a LOD-derived forcing, integrated and then an LTE modulation applied. The semi-annual impulses were allowed to bleed through as they seem to capture the fast cycling well. The LTE modulation is approximately a winding=1 for each + or – semi-annual excursion. One can see the 3.8-year aliased cycling of the principal Mf tidal factor in the middle forcing panel, and an overall 18.6-year envelope.

On recreating this fit the past few days, I couldn’t duplicate the exact same configuration from the repo, but came close: (note in all the following that the training and validation legend is reversed in the upper right regression panel)

Time series analysis of NAO data showing model and data with validation over the years.

In both cases, the same prominent 3.8-year cycles in forcing (with 18.6-year envelope) were observed, along with essentially the same LTE modulation. The algorithm behind the fit is to perturb the calibrated LOD tidal factors enough so they will start to align with the NAO time series, especially synching the phases since timing is so crucial. In general, it’s difficult to achieve the same height of excursions, but the running windowed correlation (bottom panel with GREEN curve) shows a uniform accounting of the full cycling. Below is a DTW metric trained fit, which does a dynamic time warp on the time-axis, thus relaxing the alignment on each excursion. The improvement is subtle.

Time series plot showing Site#nao data with blue and red lines representing model and measured values over years from 1950 to 2020.

The alignment with the original LOD calibration was shifted by approximately 2-years (see below), but this could also be due to derivative adjustments. It’s not clear which order of forcing that the NAO is responding to — is it just the original dLOD/dt or some higher order acceleration? A higher derivative would generate a lead factor, i.e. a sin(t) derivative would turn into a cos(t) lead term.

Line graph depicting tidal force time series from 1960 to 2020, featuring two datasets: 'LOD' in blue and 'model' in red, showing fluctuating values between -3 and 2.

Different perspective

A time series graph titled 'Tidal for time series' showing fluctuating values across a timeline from 1990 to 2020. The data is represented with red and blue colored areas indicating variations in values over time.

Shorter interval

Line graph depicting tidal force time series from 1962 to 1967, showing the value on the vertical axis with red and blue lines representing different models and variations.

The NAO used above covers years after 1950 and stops short of 2018. On Climate Explorer: Monthly time series one can find other NAO variants that cover a wider timespan interval. In the plot below, the NAO is extended back to 1880 and forward to nearly present day. The back extrapolation is not the best but the forward beyond 2015 is excellent. The fact that the LTE modulation in the middle right panel still shows a strong low-order winding indicates that the fundamental patter remains across the entire timespan but is structurally sensitive to the fitted parameters.

Time series graph of NAO values from 1880 to 2020, showing model and data trends.
A line graph depicting a tidal force time series from 1960 to 2020, with red lines representing LOD and blue lines indicating the model values. The graph shows fluctuations in values over the years.

Refitting by including the back-extrapolated interval prior to 1953 does not significantly reduce the correlation in the excluded post-2015 interval.

Top left: Time series graph for site NAO from 1880 to 2020 showing model and data values.

Structural sensitivity in this class of models is significant. Think about how tides with daily to monthly variation need to be calibrated to effects that evolve over decades. This will take time and effort to improve, likely with input from others that can contribute subtleties that I have missed. Yet, doing this kind of deep fitting exercise is at odds with those that have been indoctrinated to a weather mindset of predicting only what’s in store for the immediate future.

A time-series graph depicting the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) with data showing 80 peak excursions since 1950.
The answer to why not predict the next <blank>?
RealClimate: Unforced Variations: June 2026

Thread on tidal modeling

Someone on Twitter suggested that tidal models are not understood “The tides connection to the moon should be revised.”. Unrolled thread after the “Read more” break

Continue reading →

Difference Model Fitting

By applying an annual impulse sample-and-hold on a common-mode basis set of tidal factors, a wide range of climate indices can be modeled and cross-validated. Whether it is a biennial impulse or annual impulse, the slowly modulating envelope is roughly the same, thus models of multidecadal indices such as AMO and PDO show similar skill — with cross validation results evaluated here for a biennial impulse. Now we will evaluate for annual impulse.

Continue reading →

Lunar Torque Controls All

Mathematical Geoenergy

The truly massive scale in the motion of fluids and solids on Earth arises from orbital interactions with our spinning planet. The most obvious of these, such as the daily and seasonal cycles, are taken for granted. Others, such as ocean tides, have more complicated mechanisms than the ordinary person realizes (e.g. ask someone to explain why there are 2 tidal cycles per day). There are also less well-known motions, such as the variation in the Earth’s rotation rate of nominally 360° per day, which is called the delta in Length of Day (LOD), and in the slight annual wobble in the Earth’s rotation axis. Nevertheless, each one of these is technically well-characterized and models of the motion include a quantitative mapping to the orbital cycles of the Sun, Moon, and Earth. This is represented in the directed graph below, where the BLUE ovals indicate behaviors that are fundamentally understood and modeled via tables of orbital factors.

The cyan background represents behaviors that have a longitudinal dependence
(rendered by GraphViz
)

However, those ovals highlighted in GRAY are nowhere near being well-understood in spite of being at least empirically well-characterized via years of measurements. Further, what is (IMO) astonishing is the lack of research interest in modeling these massive behaviors as a result of the same orbital mechanisms as that which causes tides, seasons, and the variations in LOD. In fact, everything tagged in the chart is essentially a behavior relating to an inertial response to something. That something, as reported in the Earth sciences literature, is only vaguely described — and never as a tidal or tidal/annual interaction.

I don’t see how it’s possible to overlook such an obvious causal connection. Why would the forcing that causes a massive behavior such as tides suddenly stop having a connection to other related inertial behaviors? The answers I find in the research literature are essentially that “someone looked in the past and found no correlation” [1].

Continue reading →

NAO and the Median Filter

a random quote

“LLMs run a median filter on the corpus”

The North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) time-series has always been intimidating to analyze. It appears outwardly like white-noise, but enough scientists refer to long periods of positive or negative-leaning intervals that there must be more of an underlying autocorrelation embedded in it. To reduce the white noise and to extract the signal requires a clever filtering trick. The desire is that the filter preserve or retain the edges of the waveform while reducing the noise level. The 5-point median filter does exactly that at a minimal complexity level, as the algorithm is simply expressed. It will leave edges and steep slopes alone as the median will naturally occur on the slope. That’s just what we want to retain the underlying signal.

Once applied, the NAO time-series still appears erratic, yet the problematic monthly extremes are reduced with the median filter suppressing many of them completely. If we then use the LTE model to fit the NAO time-series (with a starting point the annual-impulsed tidal forcing used for the AMO), a clear correlation emerges. The standing-wave modes of course are all high, in contrast to the one low mode for the AMO, so the higher frequency cycling is expected yet the fit is surprisingly good for the number of peaks and valleys it must traverse in the 140+ year historical interval.

The Big 10 Climate Indices

The above diagram courtesy of Karnauskus

These correspond to the geographically defined climate indices

Overall I’m confident with the status of the published analysis of Laplace’s Tidal Equations in Mathematical Geoenergy, as I can model each of these climate indices with precisely the same (save one ***) tidal forcing, all calibrated by LOD. The following Threads allow interested people to contribute thoughts

  1. ENSO – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/CuWS8MFu8Jc
  2. AMO – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/Cuh4krjJTLN
  3. PDO – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/Cuu0VCypIi5
  4. QBO – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/CuiKQ5tsXCQ
  5. SOI (Darwin & Tahiti) – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/Cuu2IkBJh55 => MJO
  6. IOD (East & West) – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/Cuu9PYvJAG2
  7. PNA – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/CuvAVR7JN7R
  8. AO – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/CuvEz37JPFV
  9. SAM – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/CuvLZ2CMt1X
  10. NAO – https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/CuvNnwns2la

(*** The odd-one out is QBO, which is a global longitudinally-invariant behavior, which means that only a couple of tidal factors are important.)

Is the utility of this LTE modeling a groundbreaking achievement? => https://www.threads.net/@paulpukite/post/CuvNnwns2la

Highly-Resolved Models of NAO and AO Indices

Revisiting earlier modeling of the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) and Arctic Oscillation (AO) indices with the benefit of updated analysis approaches such as negative entropy. These two indices in particular are intimidating because to the untrained eye they appear to be more noise than anything deterministically periodic. Whereas ENSO has periods that range from 3 to 7 years, both NAO and AO show rapid cycling often on a faster-than-annual pace. The trial ansatz in this case is to adopt a semi-annual forcing pattern and synchronize that to long-period lunar factors, fitted to a Laplace’s Tidal Equation (LTE) model.

Start with candidate forcing time-series as shown below, with a mix of semi-annual and annual impulses modulating the primarily synodic/tropical lunar factor. The two diverge slightly at earlier dates (starting at 1880) but the NAO and AO instrumental data only begins at the year 1950, so the two are tightly correlated over the range of interest.

(click on any image to expand)

The intensity spectrum is shown below for the semi-annual zone, noting the aliased tropical factors at 27.32 and 13.66 days standing out.

The NAO and AO pattern is not really that different, and once a strong LTE modulation is found for one index, it also works for the other. As shown below, the lowest modulation is sharply delineated, yet more rapid than that for ENSO, indicating a high-wavenumber standing wave mode in the upper latitudes.

The model fit for NAO (data source) is excellent as shown below. The training interval only extended to 2016, so the dotted lines provide an extrapolated fit to the most recent NAO data.

Same for the AO (data source), the fit is also excellent as shown below. There is virtually no difference in the lowest LTE modulation frequency between NAO and AO, but the higher/more rapid LTE modulations need to be tuned for each unique index. In both cases, the extrapolations beyond the year 2016 are very encouraging (though not perfect) cross-validating predictions. The LTE modulation is so strong that it is also structurally sensitive to the exact forcing.

Both NAO and AO time-series appear very busy and noisy, yet there is very likely a strong underlying order due to the fundamental 27.32/13.66 day tropical forcing modulating the semi-annual impulse, with the 18.6/9.3 year and 8.85/4.42 year providing the expected longer-range lunar variability. This is also consistent with the critical semi-annual impulses that impact the QBO and Chandler wobble periodicity, with the caveat that group symmetry of the global QBO and Chandler wobble forcings require those to be draconic/nodal factors and not the geographically isolated sidereal/tropical factor required of the North Atlantic.

It really is a highly-resolved model potentially useful at a finer resolution than monthly and that will only improve over time.

(as a sidenote, this is much better attempt at matching a lunar forcing to AO and jet-stream dynamics than the approach Clive Best tried a few years ago. He gave it a shot but without knowledge of the non-linear character of the LTE modulation required he wasn’t able to achieve a high correlation, achieving at best a 2.4% Spearman correlation coefficient for AO in his Figure 4 — whereas the models in this GeoenergyMath post extend beyond 80% for the interval 1950 to 2016! )